Back to Blog
Leadership10 min read

Do Not Hire a COO to Fix a Business You Have Not Defined

A senior operator can multiply a strong management system. They cannot rescue an undefined role, unclear authority and a founder who continues making every decision behind them.

The owner is exhausted and decides the business needs a heavyweight operator. A large salary is agreed, the new executive is introduced and the owner expects to step back. Six months later, both are frustrated. Managers still go around the new hire, priorities remain unclear and the owner is solving the same problems as before.

The hiring decision may not have been wrong. The role was undefined. The business asked one person to ‘sort everything out’ without clear outcomes, authority, data or a management rhythm. That is not delegation. It is an expensive transfer of confusion.

A COO is a multiplier, not a magician. If the operating model is unclear, the hire multiplies ambiguity.

Decide Which Role You Actually Need

An operations director normally owns manufacturing performance: safety, quality, delivery, cost, people and continuous improvement. A general manager may own the full performance of a site or division, including its P&L. A COO usually works across the enterprise, translating strategy into an operating model and coordinating several functions or leaders.

Titles vary, so define the outcome rather than shopping for a title. If the problem is weak factory performance, hiring a broad strategic executive may be unnecessary. If several functions and sites need to operate as one system, a stronger enterprise role may be justified.

Warning Signs You Are Hiring a Firefighter

  • .The brief is a long list of problems rather than three or four measurable outcomes
  • .Nobody can explain what decisions the new leader can make without the founder
  • .The owner has not defined their own role after the hire
  • .Management information is late, disputed or missing
  • .The organisation expects the newcomer to impose discipline while the founder bypasses it

Build the Foundation Before Recruitment

The Seven-Part Senior-Hire Test

1
Define the business outcomeState what must be materially different after twelve months: delivery, margin, leadership depth, cash, capacity or multi-site control. Avoid a vague mandate to fix operations.
2
Map the operating flowMake the core journey from enquiry to cash visible, including handoffs, constraints and current ownership. The new leader needs a business to improve, not a mystery to decode.
3
Clarify decision rightsSpecify authority over people, suppliers, pricing, capital, schedules and customer recovery. Responsibility without authority creates an executive-shaped bottleneck.
4
Establish the management rhythmCreate the weekly and monthly reviews, scorecard and accountability expectations the leader will own. Do not expect one hire to invent governance while fighting daily fires.
5
Define the founder's new jobWrite down what the founder will continue to own and what they will stop doing. ‘Strategy’ is too vague; name markets, customers, acquisitions, product or board responsibilities.
6
Choose the right levelMatch the complexity of the role to the business. An excellent operations director may deliver more value than a COO title with an enterprise salary and no enterprise remit.
7
Design the first 100 daysPlan listening, relationship transfer, baseline measures, early decisions and staged ownership. Avoid demanding instant transformation before the leader understands the operation.

The Founder Can Quietly Destroy the Role

If supervisors continue bringing problems directly to the founder and receiving decisions, the new leader has no real authority. If the owner privately reverses decisions, negotiates separate priorities or rescues every difficult moment, the organisation learns that the old system remains.

Support does not mean disappearing. Agree boundaries, review performance and coach judgement. But when the decision is within the role's authority, allow the person to own it, including the learning that comes from a non-fatal mistake.

The Role Test

Can you explain the new leader's outcomes, authority, scorecard and first 100 days in one page? If not, the recruitment process is starting too early.

Your Action Checklist

  • .Write the three measurable outcomes the senior hire must deliver in year one
  • .Choose whether the business needs an operations director, general manager or COO remit
  • .Document the decisions the role can make without owner approval
  • .Define the founder's responsibilities and stop-doing list after appointment
  • .Build a staged 100-day onboarding and relationship-transfer plan

Final Thought

Hiring senior operational leadership can change the trajectory of a growing business. Do the design work first. Give the person a clear outcome, real authority and a management system they can strengthen. Otherwise, you are not hiring a leader. You are hiring someone to stand beside you in the same confusion.

Put This Into Practice

Find Where Your Business Is Stuck

The CEO Scorecard gives you a clear view of the constraints affecting profit, cash, the team and your time.

Take the CEO ScorecardExplore CEO Advisory

Continue Reading

Back to all articles